Key Takeaways
- Intuit, the maker of TurboTax, agreed to a $141 million settlement after allegations that it deceptively marketed its tax preparation services as free to consumers who were actually ineligible for the free option.
- Millions of eligible consumers are receiving compensation automatically, with most payments ranging from $29 to $30, as part of a multi-state agreement led by state attorneys general and supported by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
- The settlement imposes new marketing restrictions on Intuit to prevent future deceptive practices and highlights the importance of transparency and consumer protection in the tax preparation industry.
Overview of the TurboTax Lawsuit
The TurboTax lawsuit centers on allegations that Intuit Inc., the company behind TurboTax, misled millions of consumers by advertising its tax preparation software as “free” when, in reality, many users were not eligible for the free service. This led to a multi-state investigation and a $141 million settlement intended to compensate affected consumers and prevent similar deceptive practices in the future.
The case was brought to public attention by various state attorneys general, including Pennsylvania Attorney General Michelle Henry, who announced the settlement and highlighted the deceptive marketing tactics used by Intuit. The lawsuit and subsequent settlement have broad implications for both consumers and the tax preparation industry as a whole.
Background and Allegations
The Free File Program and Deceptive Marketing
The IRS Free File Program was designed to provide free tax preparation services to low- and moderate-income taxpayers. Intuit participated in this program, offering a version of TurboTax that was supposed to be free for eligible users. However, according to the allegations, Intuit steered many eligible consumers away from the truly free version and toward paid products through misleading advertising and website design.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) found that Intuit’s marketing practices were deceptive, as the company promoted TurboTax as “free” in its advertising campaigns, even though the free option was not available to many consumers. The FTC’s official press release on this finding can be found here.
Who Was Affected?
The settlement applies to consumers who:
- Were eligible for the IRS Free File Program,
- Began their 2016, 2017, or 2018 federal tax returns using Intuit’s free software,
- But were ultimately charged for TurboTax services.
According to the California Attorney General’s Office, millions of Americans, particularly low-income individuals, were impacted by these practices.
The Settlement: Terms and Distribution
Settlement Amount and Administration
Intuit agreed to pay $141 million to settle the claims. The settlement is being administered by Rust Consulting, a third-party administrator. Eligible consumers are being notified via email, and payments are being distributed automatically by check. There is no need for consumers to file a claim to receive their compensation.
For more information on the settlement process and eligibility, consumers can visit the official settlement website.
Payment Details
The amount each consumer receives depends on the number of tax years for which they qualify. Most consumers are receiving payments between $29 and $30 per qualifying year. Checks began being distributed in May 2023, as confirmed by ProPublica.
Tax Implications
It is important for recipients to understand the tax implications of their settlement payments. According to TurboTax’s own support page, any interest earned on the settlement funds is considered taxable income and should be reported on a Form 1099-INT. More details can be found on the TurboTax support site.
Regulatory Actions and Consumer Protection
Role of the FTC and State Attorneys General
The FTC played a significant role in investigating and publicizing Intuit’s deceptive marketing. The FTC’s decision is part of a broader effort to hold companies accountable for misleading consumers, particularly in industries that affect financial well-being.
State attorneys general across the country, including those in Pennsylvania and California, led the legal action against Intuit. Their coordinated efforts resulted in the multi-state settlement and new restrictions on Intuit’s marketing practices. The Pennsylvania Attorney General’s announcement can be found here.
New Restrictions on Intuit
As part of the settlement, Intuit is barred from advertising its TurboTax software as “free” unless it is truly free for all consumers. This provision is designed to prevent future deceptive practices and ensure that consumers are not misled about the cost of tax preparation services.
The Santa Clara County Counsel’s Office highlights the importance of these new restrictions in protecting low-income residents from overpaying for tax preparation.
Broader Implications for the Tax Preparation Industry
Transparency and Accountability
The TurboTax lawsuit has drawn national attention to the issue of deceptive marketing in the tax preparation industry. It underscores the need for greater transparency and accountability from companies that provide essential financial services to consumers.
The Role of Regulatory Bodies
This case also highlights the critical role of regulatory bodies like the FTC and state attorneys general in protecting consumers from unfair business practices. Their actions ensure that companies adhere to ethical standards and that consumers have access to the services they are entitled to.
Consumer Awareness
For consumers, the lawsuit serves as a reminder to be vigilant about marketing claims, especially when it comes to financial products and services. It is important to verify eligibility for free or discounted services and to seek out official information when in doubt.
What Affected Consumers Should Know
How to Handle Settlement Payments
If you received a settlement payment, you do not need to take any action to claim your funds. Payments are being sent automatically to eligible consumers. If you have questions about your eligibility or the settlement process, visit the official settlement website.
Reporting Settlement Income
Remember that any interest earned on your settlement payment is taxable and should be reported on your tax return. Consult the TurboTax support page or a tax professional for guidance.
Ongoing Oversight
The settlement includes ongoing oversight to ensure that Intuit complies with the new marketing restrictions. Regulatory agencies will continue to monitor the company’s practices to protect consumers in the future.
Conclusion
The TurboTax lawsuit and resulting $141 million settlement represent a significant step forward in protecting consumers from deceptive marketing in the tax preparation industry. The case demonstrates the importance of regulatory oversight and the need for companies to be transparent and honest in their advertising. As settlement payments are distributed, affected consumers are receiving compensation for being misled, and new safeguards are in place to prevent similar issues in the future.
For attorneys and legal professionals seeking deeper insights or case law research, visit Counsel Stack for comprehensive legal resources.
Disclaimer:
This guide provides a general overview of the TurboTax lawsuit and settlement. It is not legal advice. The information is based on publicly available sources and may be subject to change, especially if new developments arise. For specific legal questions or advice, consult a qualified attorney.
